Are mammograms a waste of time?

A large, long-term study came out late yesterday in a major medical journal, BMJ, that says mammography may be a waste of time and money. The actual study says that screening for cancer with mammography in women ages 40 to 59 “does not reduce mortality from breast cancer” in places where treatment is available.

Are mammograms really necessary?

Fact: The American College of Radiology recommends annual screening mammograms for all women over 40, regardless of symptoms or family history. “Early detection is critical,” says Dr. Sarah Zeb.

Why you shouldn’t get a mammogram?

Overdiagnosis and overtreatment

Screening mammograms can often find invasive breast cancer and ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS, cancer cells in the lining of breast ducts) that need to be treated. But it’s possible that some of the invasive cancers and DCIS found on mammograms would never grow or spread.

Are mammograms useless?

Screening mammograms do not reduce death from breast cancer. There is no reliable evidence that having a screening mammogram reduces death by breast cancer on a population basis.

Can I skip mammogram?

Don’t skip your mammogram because you’ve had a history of normal results. “Even if you’ve always had normal mammograms, you should still get them regularly to be sure we’re not missing anything,” Omofoye says. Breast tissue changes over time, and cancer can develop at any time.

Is there an alternative to a mammogram?

Ultrasound is an essential tool in medicine. It is a safe, non-invasive technique that uses sound waves to build up pictures of the body. It is common to have an ultrasound alongside a mammogram to confirm a diagnosis of breast cancer.

At what age are mammograms no longer necessary?

For women with no history of cancer, U.S. screening guidelines recommend that all women start receiving mammograms when they turn 40 or 50 and to continue getting one every 1 or 2 years. This routine continues until they turn about 75 years of age or if, for whatever reason, they have limited life expectancy.

Is the radiation from mammograms harmful?

Mammograms are a generally safe and mostly effective way to help detect breast cancer. Although they do expose people to small amounts of radiation, they typically will not cause harm unless the person experiences repeated exposure and long-term screenings.

Can a mammogram detect other cancers?

The most important and obvious thing mammograms can pick up on is breast cancer tumors. However, mammograms can also pick up on other things, as well.


Are mammograms banned in Europe?

Although screening parameters differ in many parts of Europe than in the US, there is no outright ban of mammography in any European country that I could find.

What if I don’t want a mammogram?

However, free or low-cost mammograms are often offered through community or national programs, especially in October which is breast cancer awareness month. If you aren’t able to afford a mammogram, ask a representative at your local health department or hospital for information about free or low-cost mammograms.

What is the false negative rate of mammography?

According to data from the Breast Cancer Detection Demonstration Project (BCDDP), the false-negative rate of mammography is approximately 8-10%. About 1-3% of women with a clinically suspicious abnormality, a negative mammogram, and a negative sonogram may still have breast cancer.

Do mammograms increase survival?

The widespread use of mammography, better treatments and supportive care have allowed a progressive improvement in prognosis and a sustained 1%–2% increase in survival every year over the last 30 years in developed countries [1, 3].

Can I have a mammogram while breastfeeding?

Mammogram CAN be done in a breastfeeding woman. Ideally, it should be done with an experienced mammographer who knows the woman is breastfeeding, as the images will be more complex. She should empty her breasts as much as possible right before the mammogram, either by nursing or pumping.